Comparison
Encrypted photo apps for iPhone, and how much each one tells you
Pick the vault whose own pages let you check its encryption: the cipher, how the key is made and kept, and what the encryption covers. Of ten other vaults read for this page, four name a cipher, three use only the word, and three don’t mention encryption in their listing. Sealed encrypts every file with AES-256-GCM before it is saved. Each file gets its own random 256-bit key, and that key is sealed with your vault key. The table shows where each one stands and where it says so.
On this page
Disclosure. Sealed is made by Loopware LLC. Sealed is in the table. Its row comes from the app and its listing text. The other rows quote each app’s own pages, read on the date shown. We tested none of them.
Five levels of saying “encrypted”
Read a vault’s listing and help pages, and put it on this scale. Each level adds something you could check.
- Silent. The text never uses the word.
- The word only. “Encrypted” with no cipher, or the word used only for a cloud backup.
- A named cipher. For example AES-256-GCM.
- A cipher and a key design. Where the key comes from and what opens it.
- A written specification. Formats and test values that someone else can check against.
A higher level is not proof. It is a claim you can hold an app to.
Where each app stands
| App | What its own pages say, and where |
|---|---|
| Sealed: a written specification | Sealed encrypts every file with AES-256-GCM before it is saved. Each file gets its own random 256-bit key, and that key is sealed with your vault key. Your vault key is a random 256-bit key. It is not made from your passcode. The formats are written out in Sealed’s encryption specification. |
| Vaultaire: a cipher and a key design | The listing names AES-256-GCM. Its site says a pattern unlocks a random key that encrypts the files, and that the cipher covers metadata and thumbnails too. Store record, 13 Nov 2026; site, 28 Oct 2026. |
| Private Photo Vault: a named cipher, and a key design for its backup | Its FAQ names AES-256. Its Cloud Vault page adds a second AES-256 layer before upload, says the Cloud Vault password makes the key and is never uploaded, and names Argon2id for the password. The App Store text uses “encrypted” only for that backup. FAQ, Cloud Vault page and store record, 28 Oct 2026; store record again 13 Nov 2026. |
| LockMyPix: a named cipher | The listing names AES in CTR mode and says photos, videos, documents and notes are encrypted. Store record, 13 Nov 2026. |
| Keepsafe: a named cipher | Its help center names 256-bit AES and says files are encrypted at rest. The same help center says Keepsafe is not designed as a completely zero-knowledge app. The two pages showed ages of six and seven years when read. Encryption, who can see content, 28 Oct 2026. |
| PV, Secret Photo Album - SA, 1Locker: the word only | Each listing says the vault’s files are encrypted and names no cipher. PV, SA, 1Locker, 28 Oct and 13 Nov 2026. |
| SPV, Safe Lock, Unlock: silent | Read in full, the listing text doesn’t use the word encrypt in any form. SPV, Safe Lock, Unlock, 28 Oct and 13 Nov 2026. |
An app that is silent, or gives only the word, may still encrypt well. Its pages just don’t give you anything to check. For the same scale applied to sixteen listings at once, see the Photo Vault Audit.
Which one fits. If you want to read the design before you trust it, two apps here write theirs down: Sealed in its specification, and Vaultaire on its site. If your worry is mostly the cloud copy, Private Photo Vault’s Cloud Vault page describes how its backup key is made. If the listing is all you have, a named cipher is the least to ask for.
What a cipher name leaves out
Where the key lives. A strong cipher with a key anyone can reach protects little. Your vault key is kept in the iPhone Keychain, on this device only, and it can be read only while the phone is unlocked. Without Maximum Security, the app can read your vault key whenever the phone is unlocked, because the key sits in the Keychain.
What the key is made from. A key built from a short passcode is only as hard to guess as the passcode. Your vault key is a random 256-bit key. It is not made from your passcode. Your passcode is a gate in front of the app. It is not part of the key.
What else is covered. Names, notes and thumbnails can tell a story on their own. Names, notes and the fields of a record are sealed with your vault key too, not just the photos. Thumbnails are encrypted like the photos, and Sealed wipes the decrypted copies it shows in the grid when the vault locks.
What happens to the backup. Apple’s overview says that with standard data protection Apple holds the keys for iCloud Photos (Apple Support, 102651). A vault that encrypts before upload doesn’t depend on that. Files, names, notes and record fields are encrypted on your iPhone before they are uploaded, so iCloud receives only ciphertext.
For the iPhone side of the story, read are photos encrypted on iPhone.
Where Sealed helps, and where it doesn’t
It helps if you want the cipher, the key and the formats in writing. Sealed encrypts every file with AES-256-GCM before it is saved. Your vault key is a random 256-bit key. It is not made from your passcode. See how Sealed’s encryption works.
It helps if you want files checked for tampering. Large files are encrypted in chunks, and Sealed refuses a file that has been changed, reordered or cut short.
It helps if you want the key tied to a live face. Maximum Security seals your vault key to a Secure Enclave key that can be used only after a live Face ID or Touch ID match. Maximum Security is part of Sealed Pro.
It doesn’t keep the key from the app while the phone is unlocked, unless Maximum Security is on. Without Maximum Security, the app can read your vault key whenever the phone is unlocked, because the key sits in the Keychain.
It doesn’t come with an outside audit. Sealed has not had an independent security audit. The written specification is our own description of our own app.
It doesn’t stop someone who knows your passcode. Encryption guards files at rest. Your passcode is a gate in front of the app. It is not part of the key.
Questions and answers
Is AES-256 enough to trust a vault?
It is a start. A named cipher says nothing about where the key is kept or what makes it. Ask those too. In Sealed: Your vault key is a random 256-bit key. It is not made from your passcode. Your vault key is kept in the iPhone Keychain, on this device only, and it can be read only while the phone is unlocked. Without Maximum Security, the app can read your vault key whenever the phone is unlocked, because the key sits in the Keychain.
Are my photos already encrypted in iCloud Photos?
Yes, but with standard data protection Apple keeps the keys. By default, Apple keeps the encryption keys for iCloud Photos, Notes and iCloud Drive in its own data centers so that it can help you recover them, and only the optional Advanced Data Protection makes them end-to-end encrypted.
Sources
What this page says about Sealed was checked against the app on .
- Vaultaire, Apple Lookup record (US) — the cipher named in the App Store description, read 13 Nov 2026
- Vaultaire, home page and questions — what the cipher covers and how the pattern opens the key, read 28 Oct 2026
- LockMyPix, Apple Lookup record (US) — the cipher and mode named in the App Store description, read 13 Nov 2026
- Keepsafe Support, How does Keepsafe protect my data? — 256-bit AES at rest; the page showed "6 years ago"; read 28 Oct 2026
- Keepsafe Support, Can Keepsafe see any of my content? — not designed as a completely zero-knowledge app; the page showed "7 years ago"; read 28 Oct 2026
- Private Photo Vault, FAQ — AES-256 named for the app’s data, read 28 Oct 2026
- Private Photo Vault, Cloud Vault page — an extra AES-256 layer before upload, Argon2id for the password; marked last updated September 22, 2026; read 28 Oct 2026
- Private Photo Vault, Apple Lookup record (US) — the App Store description uses encrypted only for the Cloud Vault backup, read 28 Oct 2026 and again 13 Nov 2026
- PV, Apple Lookup record (US) — the App Store text, read 28 Oct 2026 and again 13 Nov 2026
- Secret Photo Album - SA, Apple Lookup record (US) — the App Store text, read 28 Oct 2026 and again 13 Nov 2026
- 1Locker, Apple Lookup record (US) — the App Store text, read 28 Oct 2026 and again 13 Nov 2026
- SPV, Apple Lookup record (US) — the App Store text, read 28 Oct 2026 and again 13 Nov 2026
- Safe Lock, Apple Lookup record (US) — the App Store text, read 28 Oct 2026 and again 13 Nov 2026
- Unlock, Apple Lookup record (US) — the App Store text, read 28 Oct 2026 and again 13 Nov 2026
- Apple Support, iCloud data security overview (article 102651) — published January 5, 2026; who holds the keys for iCloud Photos by default, read 13 Nov 2026
- Sealed on the App Store — the listing for the app this site is about
Get Sealed
Sealed is free to download, and Sealed Pro is an optional in-app purchase.